| Economic Forum |
Overview: Asia, as predicted, has rebounded and excelled, ignoring the US sub-prime woes, but caution is needed to manage the growing risks of volatility and inflation. Asia Focus: Asian Politics, Perceptions and Reality: Politics is likely to occupy an increasing share of Asia's news headlines in the coming months with elections and rising tensions. It is important that investors have the information to understand and the right perspective to assess the impact of upcoming political events. We are no political scientists, but having on-the-ground presence give us an advantage in understanding the internal mechanics of Asian politics and avoiding some of the common mis-perceptions in assessing Asian political risk. A few non-consensus observations about China, Korea, Taiwan, Macau, and Southeast Asia are shared in this article. Economy Highlights China: Despite problems in the US and major financial markets, the Chinese economy continues its high growth and serves as an increasingly important driving force to the global economy. The stock market will be a political issue, while a new Politburo will contain Hu's successors. Indonesia: Recently, inflation has accelerated unexpectedly, raising alarms within the central bank. BI is now likely to postpone and limit any policy rate cuts in the near future. Meanwhile, a solid external payments position and an improving banking sector should support healthy economic growth in 2008. Singapore: The Singapore economy continues to defy gravity and grow above trend, despite its having expanded for the longest period since 1991 and being confronted by weak electronic exports and financial market turbulence triggered by the US sub-prime debacle. However, inflation is raising concerns about economic overheating and has prompted the MAS to opt for a stronger SGD. South Korea: Strong asset price and robust demand from China and Europe have supported the Korean economy and kept the KRW on the strong side. But a rising threat of inflation may push the BoK to resume interest rate hikes next year. Tai Hui Nicholas Kwan Beware of inflation and volatility - Asia outperformed after the US sub-prime debacle, as predicted In Asia, as we predicted two months ago in this column, initial market reaction to the US sub-prime woes was overdone and once investors were better able to access risk, markets rebounded. In fact, the speed of healing managed by the region's asset markets was much quicker than even we expected. The Fed's 50bps cut on Sep 18 drove benchmark indices of many Asian bourses to record highs, outperforming their counterparts in developed markets. While the Fed's cut was important, the region's strong fundamentals and ample liquidity constituted the foundation of this rapid rebound. However, as the Asian markets rally and liquidity accumulates, caution is needed to manage the growing risk of volatility and inflation. Asia excels with fundamentals and liquidity
Aside from fundamentals, ample liquidity is adding support to investor confidence. Our calculation of Asia money supply growth, a GDP-weighted average for the region, stood at 14% y/y for the nine economies, or 15.9% including China in Aug-07. Both figures are high by historical standard. This money growth is likely to accelerate with recent actions by some Asian central banks to cut interest rates. Thailand, Indonesia, and most recently the Philippines, are all in easing mode. On top of this, liquidity in the region is likely to be fuelled by Middle East petro-dollars, Japanese household savings (driven overseas by Japan's near-zero interest rates), and Mainland China's external surplus. The 45% year-to-date (ytd) gain of the Hang Seng Index and 85% gain in the H-share index for Chinese companies listed in HK are testimony of what markets can do when anticipating the arrival of fresh liquidity. Liquidity-fueled asset inflation is by no means limited to equities. The real estate sector in Singapore is also benefiting from the explosive combination of liquidity and confidence. Riding on the back of Integrated Resort concept and the rise in expatriates' demand for housing, the official property price index has risen for 14 consecutive quarters. In Q3-07, the index registered a 27% y/y gain, with the top-end segment seeing an even more astonishing rise. Hong Kong has also seen the number of residential property transactions surge as the real interest rate declines and consumer sentiment improves. Beware of rising inflation and volatility The current bout of inflation has been brought about by a number of factors. Elevated oil prices are an obvious one. Global increases in food prices is another, which is partly due to bad weather and partly due to increased bio-fuel generation. For those economies with USD pegs or with currencies tracking the USD closely, the recent weakness of the greenback could also be leading to higher imported inflation. In the early phase of economic recovery in Asia, the rise in input prices was often absorbed by the retailers or wholesalers, as they were reluctant to pass on the higher costs to consumers. However, following several years of profit compression and a recovery in consumer confidence, higher raw material costs are translating more directly into higher retail prices. The good news is that we expect both agricultural and oil prices to ease in coming months (see the October issue of Commodity Focus - Base metals; A five year view), which should provide some relief. However, considering the undercurrent of strong consumer demand, we believe the risk of inflation remains on the upside. As our forecast table on page 18 shows, we expect the pace of consumer price increases to pick up in 2008. This will also have a bearing on the future policy of Asian central banks. We have repeatedly highlighted the decline in correlation between the policies of the Fed and Asian central banks. Given the current economic landscape, only two economies are expected to see lower interest rates - Indonesia and the Philippines. The latest move by the Monetary Authority of Singapore to marginally steepen SGD NEER's appreciation path is a signal that the central bank is focusing more on the inflation risk, rather than external demand uncertainty. In the next six months, we continue to expect central banks in China, Japan, India, South Korea and Taiwan to increase the cost of borrowing, albeit at different speeds. Most likely, this round of asset and consumer price inflation will continue in the next 12-18 months. This may coincide with rising market volatility, brought about by over-buoyant activity in selected markets and unsteady investor risk appetite, given the uncertainties in the US housing sector and major money markets. It is therefore necessary for Asian central banks and policymakers to be more prudent in their policy, keeping a relatively tight bias. Nicholas Kwan Kelvin Lau Asian politics, perceptions and reality - Asian politics is likely to turn hotter with growing elections and tensions Politics is likely to occupy an increasing share of Asia's news headlines in the coming months. From social unrest in Myanmar and street protests in Macau, to legislature and presidential elections in Hong Kong, South Korea, Thailand and Taiwan, to various congresses in China, and cross-border tensions in the Korean peninsula and the Taiwan Straits, the region has no shortage of potential political surprises. Some of these will be market moving and some not. Some may have only temporary impacts but some could be ground shaking. It is therefore important that investors understand, and have the right perspective to assess, the impact of these events. While the Asian economic growth story is well known, Asian politics are more challenging, if not impossible, to fully understand. We are no political scientists, but our benefit of having on-the-ground presence may give us an edge in understanding some of the region's internal mechanics and political risks. Among our few non-consensus observations are: 1. China's 17th Party Congress looks great, but tells us little China's Congress looks great, but tells us little As far as the economics are concerned, the most uncertain outcome of the Party Congress is the speed, scale and scope of macro-economic tightening required for Q4 and 2008. As the Shanghai composite stock index powers through 6,000, many believe that more tightening, at least in the stock market, is necessary. However, some believe its implementation was deterred by the Congress itself, as no one wanted to rock the boat in the run-up. Some believe that such tightening will arrive earlier and stronger than generally expected. They take heart from the 50bps raise of bank Reserve Requirement Ratio announced by the central bank just two days before the Congress. Others reckon that the new People's Bank governor and securities chief will be risk adverse as they come into their jobs and will not aggressively seek tightening. As usual, much attention will focus on the new nine-man Politburo Standing Committee line-up to be approved and disclosed on the final day of the Congress. This could be a surprise for some China watchers, at least in terms of the conventional wisdom a few weeks ago. Then, it was thought that Liaoning Party boss Li Keqiang, perceived by many as Hu's chosen successor, would be engineered onto the top leadership platform, in preparation for the 18th Congress in 2012. However, if reports are to be believed, the upset would be that the current Shanghai Party Secretary, Xi Jinping, will be elevated into the successor spot. Such an outcome would be a major signal that key decisions are still made through compromise between different factions within the Party. However, that said, the chances that this will affect policy are limited. Hu's more pro-distributionist agenda will likely still be rolled out over the next five years, assuming technical difficulties can be worked out. North Korea and Taiwan are opportunities more than risks On the other hand, Taiwan's threat to become formally independent may agitate the Mainland, but it has also annoyed its principal ally, the US. Perhaps the greatest achievement of these tensions is that they have brought the two competing giants, China and the US, together with a common interest in maintaining peace and working closer together. This achievement itself provides a very important platform for regional peace and cooperation. In other words, ironically the risks of sub-regional tensions have created greater stability and therefore opportunities across the region. With the upcoming legislature and presidential elections in Taiwan, tensions are likely to escalate, putting more pressures on Taiwan's domestic economy and difficult cross-strait business. This, however, is unlikely to be sustainable, given the damage it does to the local economy and society. New leaders, whatever their political platform, will have clear incentives to rethink the confrontational approach towards the Mainland. We think the chances of a marked improvement in economic relations are high after Q1-08. Macau's economic success hides big problems Over the years, China has been pursuing fast economic growth to contain social discontent, but Macau's experience indicates that there is a limit to such a formula. In fact, growth-induced social tensions, such as the widening income gap, rising inflation, increasing pollution, as well as growing stress on families and traditional values, are emerging all over China. The Hu-Wen administration's stress on a "harmonious society" and "people-based" politics is a response to this. How far they can roll their programmes out from rhetoric in Beijing to action in the fields of Henan, coal mines of Shaanxi and smog-full streets of Chongqing will partly define how long the China miracle can last. Governance is more than political stability Indonesia has undergone a no-less challenging (if not traumatic) political transition over the past decade. Starting with the fall of President Suharto in 1998 after 32 years in office, and the breaking away of East Timor in 1999, power has been devolved away from the central government. The first direct presidential elections were held in 2004. The election was hailed as the first peaceful transition of power in Indonesia's history. While great progress has been made, the country continues to be plagued by ethnic and religious conflicts, as well as terrorist threats. In view of these, it is not surprising to see that over half of the 13 Asian economies surveyed by the World Bank saw their perceived political stability drop over the past decade, with Taiwan, Thailand, Indonesia and the Philippines posting the most significant falls (Chart 1).
However, if we look beyond political stability, the picture is somewhat different. Measured by the World Bank's Worldwide Governance Indicator (WGI), which includes six factors: "Political Stability", "Voice and Accountability", "Government Effectiveness", "Regulatory Quality", "Rule of Law" and "Control of Corruption", governance in Asia, including Southeast Asia, has seen some improvements in recent years. This helps explain Asia's enviable economic advancement, which has a strong correlation with the WGI (Chart 2). Understandably, aside from general political stability, curbing corruption, promoting accountability and upholding regulatory quality are the keys to facilitating a conducive environment for businesses to operate within, and for economies to prosper.
A clear example is Thailand, where political stability has deteriorated substantially. However, there has only been a marginal decline in government effectiveness, regulatory quality and the rule of law. In fact, with military rule, one might argue that social order has improved. While no substantial progress has been made in corruption charges against some key officials of the former government, the control of corruption has nevertheless tightened. Overall, while business confidence remains damp, normal economic activities have not been severely disrupted and the economy is managing reasonable growth. After a year's juggling, a new constitution has been born and there are high hopes that the upcoming general elections in December will see a peaceful return to civilian rule. While a new government and a new constitution will take time to establish, we do expect a coalition government to emerge, which would be good enough to facilitate an economic rebound in 2008. In Indonesia, while occasional terrorist threats may keep the country looking unsafe, law and order have broadly improved and the new electoral system has become entrenched. For some, the government's drive against corruption may have gone too far and is disrupting normal activity. Clearly, there is a significant improvement in accountability under a more decentralised political system, government effectiveness and regulatory quality also see some progress (Chart 3).
Stephen Green Jason Chang America slows, China grows - Fast growth continues; limited worries about US impact Despite problems in the US and major financial markets, the Chinese economy continues its fast growth and serves as an increasingly important driving force to the global economy. Real GDP grew officially by an eye-popping 11.5% y/y in the first half of this year, the strongest since 1995 (Chart 1). However, we think even this probably under-estimates growth by a few percentage points. Concerns have arisen again about China's ability to keep sprinting as inflation threatens, to survive a US slowdown which could hit exports, and to maintain real sector growth while anyone with any spare cash seems focused entirely on the stock market. We remain bullish though, at least in the short term, expecting the economy to grow another 11.5% y/y in H2-07 on stable investment and higher private consumption growth. Inflationary pressures are still mild, but will push the People's Bank of China (PBoC) to hike once more in 2007, by 27 bps, and two more times in Q1-08. Yet, this is unlikely to dampen growth sharply.
The drivers
The worries
And the unknowns Fauzi Ichsan The temporary return of inflation - Higher inflation makes BI cautious on further rate cuts Inflation has accelerated unexpectedly, raising alarm within the central bank, Bank Indonesia (BI). Despite a 50bps cut in the US Fed Funds Target Rate (FFTR) in Sep-07 and expected further cuts in Q4-07, BI is now likely to postpone and limit any policy rate cuts in the near future. However, this is unlikely to impede the recovery of the real economy, given previous aggressive easing. Meanwhile, a solid external payments and an improving banking sector should mean healthy economic growth in 2008.
The return of inflation 1. Ramadhan. During the fasting season of Ramadhan in Sep and Oct, consumer spending will rise and push up prices. While acknowledging the positive impact of lower US interest rates on IDR strength and growth prospects, BI said its interest rate policy will depend on the domestic inflation outlook. We believe the next BI rate cut, by 25bps to 8.0%, will be postponed from Nov to Dec. Thereafter, we expect the BI rate to be cut further to 7.5% in Q1-08, and to 7.0% in H2-08, with risk of a less aggressive cut in H2-08 to 7.25%.
Limited impact of slower rate cuts Partly due to higher bank lending, GDP growth rose to 6.3% y/y in Q2-07 (vs. market expectations of 6.1%) from 6.0% in Q1. Growth was broadly driven by consumer spending (4.7% y/y growth in Q2-07 vs. 4.5% in Q1), fixed investment (6.9% vs. 7.0%) and exports (9.8% vs. 8.9%). Consumer spending and fixed investment strengthened on the back of lower BI rates, while exports benefited from high commodity prices. Given the government's ambitious infrastructure program (toll roads and power projects are finally being launched) and its decision to accelerate the fiscal stimulus by raising its budget deficit target to 1.6% of GDP (from 1.1%) in 2007, the government is optimistic that its GDP growth target of 6.3% this year will be achieved. We are more cautious than the government, and have revised our GDP growth forecasts to 6.1% in 2007 and 6.3% in 2008 from our original 6.0% for both years.
Payments balance remains solid Meanwhile, Indonesia's current account surplus surprisingly rose to USD 5.6bn in H1-07 from USD 4.5bn in H1-06. On top of the stronger trade surplus, net worker remittances from abroad also rose, albeit slightly, to USD 2.5bn from USD 2.2bn over the same period. We expect the current account surplus to fall to USD 9.2bn (vs. BI forecast of USD 9.9bn) in 2007 from USD 9.6bn in 2006, which means Indonesia's FX reserves will rise to USD 54.8bn by YE-07 from USD 52.9bn in Sep-07 and USD 42.6bn at YE-06.
Stronger investment and imports
Nicholas Kwan Alvin Liew October Surprise! - Growth continues to accelerate in the midst of the longest upcycle since 1991 The Singapore economy continues to defy gravity and grow above trend, despite its having expanded for the longest period since 1991 and being confronted by weak electronic exports and financial market turbulence. However, rising inflation and higher business costs are raising concerns about overheating and has prompted the MAS to opt for a stronger SGD. While such measures may help to contain import price pressures, more efforts may be needed to curb asset price inflation and reduce supply side constraints. In any case, given that the economy has already grown for 17 quarters non-stop, a moderation in growth would appear inevitable, and necessary, going forward. From a breakneck growth speed of about 8% in 2007, we expect Singapore's real GDP growth to moderate to 5.7% in 2008. Growth is still strong
Following the lead of the services and construction sectors, manufacturing production also recorded significant improvement in Q3-07, having grown 12.3% y/y after an 8.3% growth in Q2. Aside from the strong performance of the bio-medical and transport engineering sectors, electronics also seems to have embarked on a gradual recovery, as reflected in the manufacturing and non-oil domestic exports data.
Construction activity remains buoyant, although the pace of expansion was slightly lowered to 15.5% y/y from 18.8% in Q2. The services sector also performed well in Q3 with an 8.1% growth, thanks to a resilient financial sector that survived the recent global market turmoil, strong tourist inflows and robust domestic demand. On a q/q seasonally-adjusted basis, which better reflects an economy's growth momentum, GDP expanded at an annualized 6.4% in Q3-07. This is lower than the 14.4% in Q2 but underlines a sustained expansion cycle that has become the longest since 1991. Going forward, we are confident that growth should be sustained in H1-08. However, we also aware that there are downside risks from any severe slowdown in the US or higher oil prices. In any case, we believe a slowdown in Singapore's growth momentum is likely in the coming quarters. While electronics exports may revive from the doldrums, growth is unlikely to be strong given a weakening US economy. Meanwhile, growth of the current drivers like bio-medical, transport engineering, finance, construction and property sectors could moderate given the high base being built and tight supplies, especially in human resources. We expect growth to ease to 7.3% y/y in Q4-07 and reach 8.0% for the full year, which is at the high end of the official forecast. As for next year, we maintain our full year forecast of 5.7%, due to our expected moderation in external demand and rising factor costs. This is still closer to the top of the MAS' 4-6% forecast range. Concerns about overheating
Forcing the hands of the MAS
However, we still believe that there are significant downside risks to US growth. For small open economies like Singapore, the negative impact from this should not be under-estimated. Therefore, we could at some point see the SGD NEER move back below the centre of the band. Should the US plunge into a sharper slowdown, it could revive concerns about Singapore's growth prospects, and even reverse the "steepening" slope perhaps even as early as the April MAS review.
Nicholas Kwan Chongwoo Chun Eunhye Yoon Won on demand Partly boosted by the second North-South summit held in Pyongyang early this month, and partly buoyed by government pump-priming in the run-up to the Dec-07 presidential elections, sentiment in South Korea has stayed positive despite the threats of US slowdown and global financial market turbulence. Strong asset price and robust demand from China and Europe have supported the Korean economy and kept the KRW on the strong side. However, the rising threat of inflation may ultimately push the Bank of Korea (BoK) to resume interest rate hikes, probably in as early as Q1-08. Resilient economic growth In the real sector, exports dropped by 0.4% y/y in Sep-07, largely due to public holidays that came earlier and were longer than the previous year. Net of holidays, daily exports actually increased by 17% from USD 1.3bn in Aug-07 to USD 1.52bn in Sep. While exports of consumer goods like home electronics and autos were dampened by weak US demand, exports of capital goods like ship, steel and machinery were boosted by strong demand from the EU, China and the Middle East. Going forward, the payback of less holidays in the subsequent month implies that export growth should rebound in Oct-07.
Wealth effect boosts consumption
Threats of inflation
Won on demand Higher rates expected in 2008
Presidential elections not a non-event
All rights reserved. © Standard Chartered Bank 2007 |