| Economic Forum |
Overview : Over the past month, many Asian currencies and markets once again scaled new highs. Strong economic growth, solid trade and investment flows, ample liquidity all contributed to the exuberance. But more importantly, investor confidence was underscored by policy credibility and continuity of the Asian establishments, rather than by confidence in individual policymaker. Asia Focus: Intra-Asia Trade Leads Growth : Asia is no longer the world's single largest trade surplus accumulator, but it will remain the target of trade disputes, especially China. While China's trade surplus largely came from its serving as Asia's export platform, it has also become the most important export market in Asia. China is the single most important driver of intra-Asia trade, which in turn is the region's most important growth source. While Asia's overall trade surplus may taper, its growth momentum is likely to be sustained by growing regional economic integration, facilitated by a maze of free trade agreements, and strong growth in China and India. Economy Highlights China : We think the central bank's efforts to tighten liquidity will push up lending rates and take some of the froth off investment in 2006. Moderate CNY appreciation will have a mild dampening effect too. Indonesia : Having bitten the bullet and reshuffled his economic team, President Yudhoyono has turned last August's IDR mini-crisis half-way into a blessing in disguise. In the coming months, it is essential that the government makes more determined moves to boost infrastructure and investor confidence. Korea : Strong growth momentum and a more hawkish central bank are likely to drive interest rates higher, but this would also mean that the subsequent rate cut may come early, as soon as next February. New Zealand : The economy is slipping into a technical recession. The government's policy options are narrowing. By insisting no policy response before clear evidence of inflation peak-out, the RBNZ may lag in the next down-cycle. by Mike Moran Credibility and Continuity - Strong Q1-06 growth to underpin solid fundamentals, but ample liquidity will force Asian central banks' hands further. Over the past month, many Asian currencies and markets once again scaled new highs. Strong economic growth, solid trade and investment flows, ample liquidity all contributed to the exuberance. But more importantly, investor confidence was underscored by policy credibility and continuity of the Asian establishments, rather than by confidence in individual policymaker. In the same respect, the significance of President Hu Jintao's upcoming US visit lies not so much on Hu's personal achievement, but on the developments put in motion in the run-up to his visit. It is testament to Asia's new and improved fundamentals that events of recent months have failed to shake confidence in the region. The most recent example is the political tensions in Thailand, leading to Prime Minister Thaksin's resignation earlier this month. Ten years ago, street protests and conflicts of this magnitude would have sent shudders down the spines of foreign investors as they rushed for the exits. But not so this time. The THB is actually 3% stronger than it was before the political impasse erupted and markets are still not sure who will form the next government as yet. Thailand's benchmark SET stock index even made new highs of 770 following Thaksin's resignation. Solid growth and ample liquidity Confidence comes from credibility and continuity In Korea, the change over in central bank governorship, Lee Sung Tae taking over from Park Seung, also passed with little incident. Again, the theme is policy credibility and continuity. Lee is a career central banker, his personality and views are well-known in the market and the establishment and his policies are closely aligned with the departing Park. Sentiment in Asia, despite recent volatility, is driven not only by sound fundamentals and outlook for growth, but also the perception that macroeconomic policies will stay both credible and continual even when changes do arise, expectedly or otherwise. Hu's US visit 1) Senators' Schumer and Graham's China visit, scheduled ahead of Hu's trip, has helped quieten the frenzy of protectionist rhetoric that was threatening to boil over. Their discussions with Beijing have clearly improved the depth of policy understanding especially on the need to develop China's onshore FX market as a precondition towards a more liberal FX regime. Postponing their bill till September effectively buys China more time to implement change but doesn't let China off the hook. For now, the Grassley-Baucus bill may assume the role of standard bearer for the protectionist lobby, but it is a substantially weaker bill that runs little risk of upsetting the applecart. 2) In return, China appears to be allowing greater CNY volatility. The average weekly standard deviation of the onshore CNY close has slowly increased this year from less than 0.2% in Q4 last year to over 0.5% in April. The CNY has continued to strengthen vs. the USD too, reaching new highs of 8.0050 on April 12, and it is only a matter of time before the psychological 8.00 level is broken. But its relevance will be confined to being a milestone rather than a signal for change in CNY policy. Our core view for 3% CNY appreciation this year still seems consistent with Beijing's focus on improving FX infrastructure and gradual liberalisation. More progress should be expected on this in coming months. 3) Liberalising capital outflows will serve as a 'quick fix' to alleviate pressure on the CNY before more fundamental solutions can be implemented. China's USD 5bn shopping spree at Boeing is not going to be the only choreographed deal that will see China making big ticket purchases from US companies - other deals, including Microsoft and Texas Instruments, are also in the pipeline. But potentially more significant are the new proposals announced by SAFE on April 14 that will raise quota limits of FX holdings by onshore corporates and individuals effective May 1. Qualified banks will also have greater scope in collecting onshore FX holdings to fund offshore fixed income assets. The lure of more attractive offshore yields, in spite of strengthening CNY, should alleviate pressure on the CNY to a degree but certainly not solve the issue. by Nicholas Kwan, Frances Cheung Intra-Asia trade leads growth - Global imbalance is rising, but not because of Asia Asia is no longer the world's single largest trade surplus accumulator. In fact, its merchandise trade surplus is tapering. But trade deficits of North America and EU are still growing. In this respect, Asia, especially China, will remain the target of trade disputes with the US and EU. While China serves as Asia's export platform to the rest of the world, it has also become the single most important driver of intra-Asia trade, which in turn is the region's most important growth source since the Asian financial crisis. Going forward, while the region's overall trade surplus may taper, Asia's growth momentum is likely to be sustained by growing regional economic integration, facilitated by a maze of bilateral/regional free trade agreements, as well as strong growth inertia in China and India. The good news: Asia as number two
The bad news, however, is that trade deficits of the US and EU have not shrunk. Instead, they are widening at accelerating paces. This implies no likely reduction in trade fictions in the near future, even though it is getting clearer that the more apparent trade adjustment failure came from the deficit runners rather than Asia. China: devil or saint?
Aside from serving as an export platform, China has also become an increasingly important end-market for the rest of Asia. While it is difficult to differentiate between products sold to China for export-processing purposes and those for China's own consumption, China's customs data indicates that about half of its imports are for domestic uses. This is especially the case for raw materials and machinery imports such as fuel from Indonesia and Singapore, timber from Malaysia and Indonesia, iron ore from Australia, and machinery from Japan, Korea and Taiwan. As a result, China has been the highest growth market for most Asian exporters over the past decade, with its share in total exports of these economies more than doubled (chart 3). China is now the largest export market in Asia, ranked top in Hong Kong, Korea and Taiwan, second in Japan and India, and third in Thailand and the Philippines.
China's strong imports from Asia has raised new demand in these economies, partly offsetting their concerns that strong competition from China and massive migration of industries to the Mainland would hollow out their economies. Rather than simple relocation of jobs and factories, reorganisation of supply chain and the subsequent intra-regional trade flows have facilitated better specialisation and more efficient resource allocation across Asia, promoting regional economic integration and growth - something similar to what has been and still happening in the EU and NAFTA (North America Free Trade Area). Intra-regional trade as a growth driver
FTAs and India to drive further growth
First is the proliferation of bilateral and regional free trade agreements (FTAs) in Asia, which is part of a wider global trend due to disappointment upon the failure or stagnant of multilateral trading system. In Asia, the rise in FTAs is also driven by the Asian crisis, which raised the need to increase regional economic cooperation. Since 2001, over 14 new FTAs have entered into force, centering around Singapore, China and Thailand. More FTAs are being initiated or under negotiation, such as China's proposals to New Zealand and Australia, and ASEAN's talks with Japan, Korea, Australia and New Zealand. These existing and future FTAs will effectively put every Asian economies into a maze of regional trade web. India is another hot spot in Asia's trade, albeit with a much lower magnitude than China. It accounts for just over 1% of total intra-regional trade in Asia, and around one-tenth of China's trade with the region. However, India's trade growth with Asia is phenomenal, up over 30% annually between 2002 and 2005. In particular, China's imports from India grew by 63% annually, while exports by 50%. The products traded with India are somewhat different from those among the rest of Asia. Raw and basic materials like fuels, mineral ore, animal and vegetable oils constitute the dominant parts of India-Asia trade. While the acceleration in trade growth in India over the past year was led by the services sector, trade in goods showed strong momentum as well. In manufacturing, India is characterized with skill-intensive and large-scale production. Despite its low wages and strong productivity, India's share of world trade remains low, hindered by high tariffs, poor infrastructure and high regulatory burden. Here bilateral or regional FTAs should help in pushing ahead domestic reforms and trade openness in India. by Stephen Green and Jason Chang Tight credit, low inflation, slow investment - The PBoC is keeping a tighter rein on liquidity China's economy used to run on a simple credit tap. Pump more money in and it grows; restrict the flow of funds and it slows. It is all about the volume of credit available, rather than the price of funds. With interest rate liberalisation, things are gradually changing, although the amount of credit is still crucial. Although credit is being extended faster than the credit quota should dictate, we think the central bank's (PBoC) efforts to tighten liquidity will force up lending rates and take some of the froth off investment in 2006. Moderate CNY appreciation will have a mild dampening effect too. Price matters
But the summer bounty quickly passed as the PBoC started mopping up liquidity in Q4 after a successful exchange rate reform. Chart 3 shows the commercial banks' excess reserves - funds held on deposit at the PBoC in excess of the 7.5% they must hold for regulatory reasons. The higher they are, the more liquid the banking system. The lack of the usual spike in Q4 last year shows the PBoC had successfully withdrawn the liquidity it released in summer. Between October 2005 and March 2006 the central bank had raised over-night rates by 50bps - something that would make headlines in the US, but was scarcely noticed in China.
Going forward, we expect de facto loan rates to rise moderately, we estimate 7% in Q1 2006. Money market rates are still rising, with the overnight repo expected to approach 2% by year end (that's another 50bps). Why? Our main reason is the aggressive sterilisation of FX inflows since Q4 2005. Growth of the new base money created by FX inflows has slowed considerably in Q4. That will also mean slower M2 growth. As shown in chart 4, FX inflows normally cause an increase in M2 about four months later. We would not be surprised if M2 growth eases to 14% y/y by year end from 18.8% in March 2006. However, the PBoC will likely not force up interest rates dramatically, because its number one priority is the exchange rate, i.e. managing a gradual appreciation and introducing more flexibility into the USD/CNY rate.
Inflation to ease with bumper harvest
With that in mind, we believe the market's current inflation expectation is overdone. Why? First, a good harvest last year means grain and meat prices will grow only moderately this year. Rural subsidies will boost farm production. Second, the prospects for energy price reform causing CPI to rise are distant, however regrettable that is from a policy perspective. Third, we face over-capacity in a number of key industries, including steel and cement. Our forecast for CPI in 2006 is 1.2%, well below the market's view of 2-3%. Investment to slow, but not across-the-board by Fauzi Icshan Blessing in disguise - Financial markets rallied on BI and government austerity measures Having bitten the bullet and reshuffled his economic team, President Yudhoyono has turned last August's IDR mini-crisis half-way into a blessing in disguise. In the coming months, while high interest rate and inflation will dampen economic activities, renewed market confidence and strong capital inflows could provide Indonesia with a new growth platform. It is essential that the government grasps this opportunity with more determined moves to boost infrastructure spending and investor confidence. Financial market exuberance
Trade surplus almost doubled from USD 4.7bn in Q3-05 to USD 8.1bn in Q4-05 as oil/gas imports dropped by 26% (to USD 3.7bn from USD 5.0bn) after the fuel price increases. With domestic fuel prices now closer to international prices, fuel smuggling, which had cost the country over USD 2bn in 2005, has also been significantly reduced. As a result, FX reserves rebounded to a new record high of USD 40.5bn by Mar-06, up from USD 30.2bn in Sep-05. Given large capital inflows and current account surplus, we have thus revised our USD/IDR forecast to 8,500 from 9,000 by YE-06.
A strong IDR helped to cut headline inflation to 15.7% y/y in Mar-06 from 17.1% in Dec-05. The government's decision to suspend electricity tariff hike also should help reduce inflation, probably to the lower end of BI's 7-9% target range by YE-06. While we believe the BI rate has already peaked at the current 12.75% level, the likelihood of another 25bps hike in the US Fed Funds target rate would caution BI to start cutting rates gradually only in Q3-06, when a downward inflationary trend and IDR stability are more certain. We expect BI rate to be cut by 25bps every month in H2-06 to 11.25% by YE-06.
Real sector pains To reflate the economy, the government needs to boost its spending or promote private investment. Theoretically, a saving of USD 7-10bn (2.5-3.5% of GDP) from fuel subsidy cuts should allow the government to spend more in infrastructure. However, the lack of a clear majority in parliament would affect the government's ability to push through key projects. President Yudhoyono's widespread anti-corruption drives, while good and necessary in the long-run, have affected the policy implementation in key ministries. Also, increasing regional autonomy has put infrastructure projects under local governments, many of which are lack of implementation capability. As such, the government's ability to raise infrastructure spending is limited. We expect the budget deficit to rise to only 1.0% of GDP in 2006.
Meanwhile, efforts to promote private investment would need to tackle several obstacles such as legal uncertainty, labor rigidity, regional autonomy, poor infrastructure, tax and customs issues. The government has introduced an investment policy package to simplify investment, licensing and customs procedures and to introduce tax incentives for investment in certain sectors and regions. It also proposes to abolish taxes on some agricultural products, improve services at regional tax offices and remove local taxes that hinder FDI, including the repeal of 700 local taxes and levies that are incompatible with national laws. It also tries to introduce a new investment law and revise the labour law.
Government holds the key by Chongwoo Chun Higher rates, early reversal - Strong growth momentum reinforces BoK's hawkish stance Strong growth momentum and a more hawkish central bank are likely to drive interest rates higher, pushing the policy call rate to 4.5% by August 2006, up from our original forecast of 4.25% by this May. However, this would also mean that the subsequent rate cut may come early. We now forecast the next interest rate down-cycle to start as soon as next February and would bring the call rate back to 4.0%, the current level, by May 2007. Solid growth momentum despite a strong KRW
Given the solid growth inertia, concerns about a strong KRW dampening Korea's competitiveness and near-term growth prospects are taking a backseat. Instead, a strong currency is seen as supporting the recovery of domestic demand by keeping imports cheap and inflation low. Increased outsourcing, particularly to China, also help to lower input costs and keep Korean products competitive. This may be why the BoK has remained relaxed and largely absent from the FX market. Potential threats to inflation As the economy recovers, the ratio of broad money M3 to GDP also rises steadily. Since bottoming out in Q2-05, liquidity has been rising across the market (chart 3). With growing income and expected higher domestic demand, both money supply and demand are likely to rise further. This could raise the threat of inflation if the growing volume of liquidity is not appropriately managed.
More importantly, current rebound of the economy is pushing up service employment, which is likely to add pressure on wages and service charges. With services accounting for over half of the CPI component, this could push up core inflation going forward (chart 4).
Preemptive or over-aggressive?
While an additional 25bps hike (from our original forecast) should not break the back of the Korean economy, its necessity is likely to be a close call and could well serve as the catalyst to a new down-cycle of the Korean economy. This is especially so if an end to the current electronic up-cycle and a general global slowdown starts to unfold in H2-06. While the current aggressive stance of the BoK has reinforced the strength of the KRW, it is likely that the reverse will also be true once BoK's preemptive moves shift growth to a lower gear and force for a change in its policy emphasis from price stability to growth. This may happen in as early as next February. We expect the BoK to start cutting its call rate from 4.5% to 4.25% in Feb-07, and then to 4.0% in May 2007. The KRW, however, could react well in advance of the rate moves, retracing to about 980/USD towards YE-06 and 990 by Q1-07. by Mike Moran In denial - Business confidence points to rising risks of a technical recession, albeit a mild one New Zealand is inclining towards a technical recession. As early as last summer, growth was on the wane. GDP growth in Q3-05 disappointed at +0.1% q/q, the weakest in over 2 years. This was followed by a 0.1% q/q contraction in Q4-05, confirming our suspicion. The government's policy options are narrowing, yet the Reserve Bank of New Zealand (RBNZ) remains tight lipped, keeping its cards close to its chest. By insisting no policy response before clear evidence of inflation peak-out, the RBNZ may lag in the next down-cycle. Governor Bollard's latest comments in the RBNZ's March bulletin clearly stated the central bank did not intend to cut interest rates this year unless inflation pressures ease substantially from its projections. We believe this is already happening but may take several more months to come through in the data. But until it does, the domestic economy will continue to deteriorate, albeit at a moderate pace. Pressure for a monetary response will likely build in the meantime, but it could take till Q3, either the Sept 14 or Oct 26 MPCs, before the RBNZ deem conditions pervasive enough to start the easing cycle.
The long, slow grind
Serious about inflation
Price pressures may have peaked A buoyant housing market, once a key driver for household wealth, is also moderating. Mortgage rates have climbed steadily since 2003 (chart 4), both for fixed and floating payers. As a result, sales volumes are falling back below 2005 levels whilst median price growth also slowed sharply. The more cautious property outlook will dampen consumer and new credit growth.
Rate cuts by Q3
The wild card, of course, remains in global crude prices. Oil futures have crept higher again. Another round of higher crude prices could delay the RBNZ's decision to ease policy. This risk could pose further problems for the weak current account position, leaving currency and credit ratings vulnerable.
|